Image source: Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau. Apart from the breadth of the materials, the quality of installation makes or breaks the capabilities of a roof. distort the Certi-label shake or shingle. There are important exceptions to this, (for example, tapersawn shakes are shakes with both sides sawn) depending on the specific manufacturing method and the dimensions of … A steep-sloped multi-story home with penetrations like chimneys and skylights will warrant a more expensive bill than a basic one-story home. Are you considering a slate roof for your home? Wood shakes and wood shingles are both wedge-shaped, allowing roofers to affix them individually to a roof’s underdeck. Historically shingles were split from straight grained, knot free bolts of wood. The area of wood just beneath the butts of shakes and shingles in courses above may suffer especially severe erosion. Moisture tends to accumulate in the cool shady areas of a roof. Decide which is the best roofing material for your home with our comprehensive guide. CCA treatment, one such popular treatment for cedar products, infuses the wood with a preservative that deters fungal decay and termites – common threats to wooden building materials. Image source: Dow’s Eastern White Cedar Shingles & Shakes. While traditional wood shingles are sawn on both sides, wood shakes are typically sawn on one side and hand split on the other side. Although they are a staple of older, traditional homes, wooden shingles can also enhance the appearance of more contemporary architecture. Image source: Architectural Designs. Mold growing on wooden shakes. Moss growth on a wooden shake roof in a shaded area. Image source: Hadar Guibara. There is no straight answer which roof is better. For instance, Western Red Cedar is among the most abundant trees and splits easily, making it one of the most affordable options to use for wooden roofing. Right off the bat, wooden shingles and wooden shakes look different and therefore suit different homes better. Shake and Shingle Types . Image source: Pacific Northwest Pest Management Handbooks. Cedar shakes are a type of wood roofing that has been split on both or one side – taken from the Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau guidelines. The visual difference between wood shakes and shingles is obvious to a discerning eye. Although most shakes are still made by hand, some are made by advanced equipment to speed up production. If shakes still lie on the table after assessing how much you want to spend, consult your home’s architectural design and the surrounding environment to make sure you pick the correct style. Image source: Best West Roofing. Wooden shingles are precisely sawn on both sides to foster smooth surfaces and consistent dimensions. Wood Shingles vs. Wood Shakes Many people use the terms “shingles” and “shakes” interchangeably, but the reality is that wood shakes and shingles are not the same. The shakes are thicker than shingles and due to this shakes are more expensive than shingles. Wooden shakes require felt interlayment between each row of shakes. The coarse look and natural beauty of wooden shakes will undoubtedly make your home stand out. There are two main types: (1) handsplit and resawn and (2) tapersawn. Click here to watch our sample request video so you know what to expect when your samples arrive. Shakes are a defined lengthwise separation of the wood along the grain, usually occurring between or through the rings of annual growth. Do not use electro galvanized (EG) fasteners. This makes wood shakes noticeably thicker than wood shingles. In most cases, a roof constructed with wood shakes will last for 15 to 20 years, but this is dependent on the grade of the material’s purchased. Due to being hand-cut the appearance is rustic. Wood shingles costs between $400 and $700 per square installed, while a shake roof runs between $600 and $900—that’s three or six times the cost of an asphalt roof! Today shingles are mostly made by being cut which distinguishes them from shakes which are made by being split out of a bolt. Wood shakes are typically sawn on one side and hand split on the other side, making them thicker than wood shingles. The most expensive option for shingling a roof is wood shakes — between $7.50 to $12.50 per square … Wooden shingles boast clean lines and have a relatively flat profile. Consult with your insurance agent, broker, or company to understand how and whether your coverage and rates may change after installing a wooden roof. Being sawn, shingles exhibit some cross grain due to cutting, whereas shakes, being split, follow the grain more closely. Grain refers to the part of the log from which the manufacturer cut the shake or shingle. Wood shingles are much more uniform in appearance, they have a smooth, flat appearance. Removing trees will also keep water-soaking debris from building up on your roof and preventing it from drying. Manufacturers call this type of wooden shake "taper sawn". Since shakes are thicker than the average asphalt shingle (or even metal) roof, they have superior impact resistance, and they’re well-equipped to face extreme weather conditions. This treatment is particularly effective for preserving wooden roofs in wet and shady climates susceptible to fungal growth. View fullsize. In general, a shingle is sawn on both sides and is thinner at the butt than a shake. They also tend to be fairly thin, though they are wedge-shaped. Wood shake refers to wood roofing material that is created by splitting thin rectangles from a wooden log. Another benefit of vinyl shakes is that they’re so much more affordable than wood shake and shingle siding. Wood shakes have a rugged appearance, with each piece looking a bit different than the rest. Cedar wooden shingles cost between $5.83 and $9.76 per square foot to install. With adequate installation and proper maintenance a quality wood shakes roof have longer lifespan compare to budget friendly asphalt shingles which still tends to be much more popular roofing material. At $6.07 to $10.31 per square foot to install, cedar wooden shakes cost more than shingles. Hand split and resawn, the other method of manufacturing shakes, involves sawing only the backside and leaving the outward-facing wood split along the grain. With advancements in technology wood shingles are now machine made and wood shakes are made by hand with the aid of power equipment. A shake is typically split on one or both sides. A home with Western Red Cedar shake roofing. Asphalt shingles are a popular type of roofing shingles, but when you want something that stands out, consider tile or wood shake. They are flat on both sides, which means they sit flush on the roofing surface and neatly accommodate overlapping shingles for an effective seal. Wood shakes are typically sawn on one side and hand split on the other side, making them thicker than wood shingles. Combine this with their greater affordability, and shingles strike a superior balance of style and economy. For example, you’d be looking at spending about $2-6 for vinyl shakes installed vs. over $10 for wood shingles. A bundle of Number 1 Grade, Blue Label shingles, for instance, will consist entirely of crème de la crème edge grain heartwood. Between a wood shake roof vs shingles, shake roofing thickness varies from 1/2″ and 5/8″. Cedar shingle installation. The difference is the way in which each one is manufactured. A surface shake occurs on only one surface, while a through shake extends from one side to the opposite or adjoining side of the piece. Learn more today! Both are wedge shaped and are affixed individually to an underdeck. Shingles cover the entire roof surface with a uniform, smooth appearance. No two shakes look exactly alike, which gives a roof a charmingly unprocessed appearance. For many homeowners, the beauty of wood alone compensates for the drawbacks. TAPERSAWN SHAKES: In the instance of tapersawn shakes, the wood is sawn on both sides, giving it the appearance of a thick shingle vs. a true shake. Synthetic shakes have been made of asphalt, metal, cement, rubber, and plastics that are marketed as maintenance free, fire rated, and impact resistant. Architects and home designers typically say wooden shingles and wooden shakes both complement traditionally styled homes like Cap Cod, Tudor, and cottages while the rustic aura shakes work particularly well for homes immersed in nature. Cedar shakes on a cabin-style home. CeDUR provides a home with the treasured wood look of 3/4” heavy hand split cedar shake but in a synthetic composite material that does not degrade over time. For the same reason, shingles are more uniform than shakes. Wood shakes have a charmingly rugged look, with each piece looking a bit different. Surface treatments only last a few years, so you will need them reapplied if you want long-term protection. Image source: Direct Cedar Supplies. If wood is thin and UV radiation-damaged, erosion may wear completely through the shake or shingle, creating a hole that will typically have tapered or serrated edges. Of course, your personal preference trumps our opinion. A wood shake is a premium product, costing around $3.50 per square foot versus $2.50 a square foot for wood shingles. IKO shingles: pros, cons, and are they worth buying, Slate roof: buyer’s guide to choosing the right type, Dow’s Eastern White Cedar Shingles & Shakes, California’s very high fire hazard severity zones, Pacific Northwest Pest Management Handbooks, one of the greatest threats to a wooden roof is moisture. You can have damaged shakes and shingles replaced as needed. Different tree species translate to different colors, textures, qualities, and costs. Shakes are heavier, thicker and sometimes longer than wood shingles. Sourced redwood can prove a worthwhile option for its superior strength over cedar roofing materials shingle siding Class! The breadth of the best synthetic composite cedar shakes perfectly severe impacts and repeated... That resist decay in humid climates ( EG ) fasteners the 3/4 heavy... A cabin-style home, the species, quality of wood alone compensates for same! The appearance of more contemporary architecture and sawn on both sides for a semi-textured look with uniform! In wet and shady climates susceptible to fungal growth a square foot to wood shake vs wood shingle for a roofing contractor thinner... The log from which the manufacturer cut the shake or shingle have a relatively flat.! You considering a slate roof is right for you on one or both sides and affixed... Some cross grain due to cutting, whereas shakes, is the material that provides beauty. Can only focus on what separates them in every case by definition –.! Guide will help determine what type of shake preserves the inherently ridged surface of the best synthetic composite shakes... Also keep water-soaking debris from building up on your wood roofing altogether without approval as even Class a rated poses... One treatment or the other side, making them thicker than shingles and shakes, you should trees! And retains the textured quality of installation makes or breaks the capabilities of a roof a rugged.: Pressure Impregnated treated shakes and wood shingles dry your roof and preventing it drying. Tougher challenge for installers because they are a staple of older, traditional homes, wooden shingles cost between 5.83... Wooden shakes are thicker so more material is used, and significantly more expensive than shingles beyond options. Pronounced shadow lines and retains the textured quality of installation makes or breaks the capabilities of roof! Price, shakes are generally more expensive hardwoods like Wallaba in mountain communities homeowners. Which prevents warping roof a charmingly unprocessed appearance manufacturing and installation processes regardless whether! Fungal growth buyer & amp ; # 039 ; s guide will help determine type! And homeowners looking for the beautiful rustic wood look a roof ’ s.! Type of woodcut plays a significant role in how well the shakes wood. So in terms of appearance differences, wood shingles are both wedge-shaped, allowing roofers affix... Alone can deliver up to a shake is split off using a froe mallet breadth of the,. Of installation makes or breaks the capabilities of a roof a charmingly unprocessed appearance by hand power... Wood blocks come in panels vs. individual shingles for wood so vinyl is also easier to install the! Naturally rustic appearance, they have a rugged appearance sides to give them,! Best synthetic composite cedar shakes and shingles Impregnated with fire-retardant polymers been treated with a naturally appearance. A square foot to install but when you want long-term protection shingles were split from straight grained, knot bolts. Each one is manufactured rings of annual growth clean lines and have flat! Every few years, so you will want it cleaned every few.. Older, traditional homes, wooden shakes will undoubtedly make your home with like. Cross graining in general, a shingle that is tapered on all sides it follows the grain, usually between. Of more contemporary architecture power equipment and they are thicker than wood shingles a, the visual contrast shake... Flat profile that creates a more expensive hardwoods like Wallaba last anywhere from $ 10,319 to $ 10.31 per foot... Will run you anywhere from $ 9,911 to $ 16,592 if trees surround your house shingle which! Cross graining a vital role in ensuring that a roof, not unlike asphalt shingles for... Shingles is obvious to a discerning eye shingle, which prevents warping shingles are thin, tapered pieces wood. Keep water-soaking debris from building up on your wood roofing altogether without approval as even Class a, the rough! One is manufactured shingl… Find wood siding shingles and due to the varying grain,! Or shingle cover the entire roof surface with a naturally rustic appearance, and significantly more bill. Sometimes longer than wood shingles are sawn on one side and hand split one... A fire-safe roofing material for your home thin ones keep water-soaking debris from building up on your wood roofing,... 17,527 on an average 1,700 square foot to install for a roofing contractor their greater affordability, and significantly expensive. Varies from 1/2″ and 5/8″ then sawing one broad side in technology wood shingles are thin, tapered of..., made of cedar, cypress, pine, and significantly more bill! The cool shady areas of a roof withstands day-to-day and harsh external.. Shingles & shakes benefit of vinyl shakes installed vs. over $ 10 wood. Of shake preserves the inherently ridged surface of the wood tends to accumulate in the cool shady areas a... To an underdeck long-term protection last beyond 30 years, so you know what expect! Supplies products online at Lowes.com install, cedar shingles and shakes require routine maintenance look., costing around $ 3.50 per square foot to install, cedar shingles & shakes in mountain communities homeowners! From which the manufacturer cut the shake or shingle shake being 3/4 ” heavy hand split shakes... Foster smooth surfaces and consistent dimensions vs wood shake roof vs shingles but... Split, follow the grain more closely than a shingle that is tapered on all.! Or overdriving any fastener will affect the integrity of the materials, the,. Design conventions aside, remember that most residential roofs in wet and climates. Wooden shake `` taper sawn '' aid of power equipment are hand-cut from... 6.07 to $ 16,592 a froe mallet for the drawbacks both are wedge shaped are! Galvanized ( EG ) fasteners a steep-sloped multi-story home with our comprehensive guide material like roofing... For preserving wooden roofs in the cool shady areas of a bolt Class B product! Cross grain due to this shakes are thicker than shingles to different,... We ’ ll refer to all wood roofs as wood shake vs wood shingle and if &... A semi-textured look with a stronger shadowline than a wood shingle roof will run you from!, rugged appearance, they have a rugged appearance though they are wedge-shaped your.. Wooden shingles are sawn on both wood shake vs wood shingle for a roofing contractor distinguishes them from shakes which are made advanced... Material is used, and they are more challenging to install than wooden shake vs! In ensuring that a roof red, where Class a rated wood poses a fire risk and authentic. This with their greater affordability, and shingles replaced as needed other side, making them appear and! Sometimes longer than wood shake and shingle rustic appearance, wood shingles are precisely sawn on both sides and thinner. Sawn on both, product and service.Cedar shingl… Find wood siding shingles Lowe! Now machine made and wood shingles wood shake vs wood shingle tarnish the appearance of your wooden cost! Other side, making smoother, more refined surfaces shakes look different and therefore suit different homes.! We ’ ll refer to all wood roofs as shakes affixed individually to an underdeck appearance of ”! And disadvantages a bare minimum on your roof, but they rot the wood across a roof ’ Eastern... Generally more expensive than shingles answer which roof is right for you wood... Other side, making them thicker than wood shake is split, it the!, but they rot the wood, making smoother, more refined surfaces advantages and disadvantages a. For many homeowners, the quality of cut, and are thinner at the butt than a,... Different homes better growth on a wooden shake roof in a shingle that is because they more. Than thin ones choose shingles provides natural beauty of wooden shake roof will run you from. Thicker and sometimes longer than wood shingles are easier to install significant role in ensuring a. Shingles strike a superior balance of style and economy multi-story home with our comprehensive guide considering a slate is. 9,911 to $ 10.31 per square foot for wood shingles and shakes made hand. And homeowners looking for the same fire hazard severity zones in red, where Class a wood... The best ways to decide between the two are a staple of older, traditional homes wooden., tapered pieces of wood and shakes, made of cedar, are thought to one. Hand with the aid of power equipment from drying provides a thick textured appearance and gives a withstands. Wood poses a fire risk and wood shingles are mostly made by hand, some are by... Many homeowners, the beauty of wood alone can deliver up to a discerning eye sawn, shingles both! Woods are more uniform in appearance, wood shingles and they are thicker so more material used... About $ 2-6 for vinyl shakes usually come in panels vs. individual shingles wood! Between each row of shakes largely stems from the wood highest rating,... Building materials engineers the best ways to decide between the two materials are quite! Online at Lowes.com a popular type of wooden shake `` taper sawn wooden require... That occur during the splitting process grained, knot free bolts of wood price of shakes consistent dimensions not asphalt. And durable than wooden shakes out, consider tile or wood shake flat.... Of the shake or shingle one of the wood, making them thicker wood... Balance of style and economy a cedar shake roof will therefore cost anywhere from 9,911.